📋 Get the Wedding Quick Start Guide!

Sponsored Content

The 40 Best Etsy Engagement Rings

When you shop via links on our site, we may earn a small commission if you make a purchase. Learn more.

For the perfect engagement ring, visit our favorite online retailers for unique items. Check out some of the best Etsy engagement rings.

etsy weddings

Whether you are a traditionalist or not, when it comes to all things wedding planning, most couples will shop for an engagement ring. However, sometimes, finding the perfect ring that doesn’t look like everyone else’s is the hardest part. That’s why we love Etsy engagement rings. 

Shopping for engagement rings on Etsy allows you and your fiance to expand your search globally. Etsy is the best online retailer for creative, handcrafted, and curated vintage pieces that you can’t find anywhere else. Not only will an Etsy unique engagement ring stand above the crowd, but you’ll also be shopping local and small! These small businesses pour their heart and soul into their products, and you can see it in the details!

Etsy rings come in all shapes and sizes and gemstones. You can search for diamond rings, moissanite rings, and vintage and antique rings. We’ve rounded up some of our favorite best engagement rings on Etsy below.  

 Etsy Diamond Rings

When you think of an engagement ring, your mind probably immediately goes to diamonds. There is nowhere that dictates what style ring has to be an engagement ring. If you want to know exactly why the diamond is the gemstone of choice for engagement rings, you can listen to B$B’s The Bouquet Toss episode here for some interesting insight.  That being said if a diamond engagement ring is what you’ve always dreamed of, but you don’t want it to be just any cut or style, then consider shopping from Etsy! Here, you’ll find traditional rings, oval rings, multiple diamond rings, eco-friendly rings,  and other interesting and beautiful cuts. Which one is your favorite?

etsy diamond rings

Diamond Solitaire Proposal Ring 

Etsy • $1,410

There is something delicate and lovely about a diamond solitaire ring. This .50 Carat ring is affordable and can be set in 14k gold, white gold, or rose gold for your own Etsy custom ring.

3 stone-etsy rings

3 Stone Diamond Ring 

Etsy • $2,910.96+

This ring from Evorden features three synthetic oval diamonds set in a 14k or 18k gold band of your choice of color. The center stone is 1.1 Carat which is flanked by .5 Carat stones in a cathedral setting.

etsy diamond engagement rings

14K Gold 2 Stone Diamond Ring 

Etsy • $649.99

If you are searching for dainty Etsy diamond engagement rings, check out this affordable 2-stone diamond ring. This .60 Carat lab-grown diamond features two stackable diamonds set on 14k gold available in white, yellow, or rose gold metal.

oval-etsy unique engagement rings

Oval Lab Grown Diamond Ring 

Etsy • $3,100+

This Etsy oval engagement ring has a minimalist design full of sparkle and shine. The 2-carat lab-grown oval diamond can sit on a 14k or 18k gold or platinum band.

cluster-engagement rings etsy

Diamond Iconic Cluster Ring 

Etsy • $329.99+

If you are looking for handmade unique engagement rings, consider this diamond cluster ring. The .018 Carat cluster is ethically sourced, eco-friendly, and can be set on a 10k, 14k, or 18k gold band.

Etsy Moissanite Engagement Ring

Moissanite is a more affordable alternative to diamonds, but it still shines just as bright. Moissanite is a gemstone that looks and feels a lot like a natural diamond. This gemstone is actually brighter and sparklier than a diamond and way cheaper. So, honestly, you can’t go wrong with an Etsy moissanite ring.  If you had to pick, which one below would you choose?

etsy moissanite engagement ring

Moissanite Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $1,498+

If you’ve ever wanted to rock (pun intended) a 3 ct ring but couldn’t afford the cost, then consider this beauty! This radiant-cut engagement ring is a stunner and can have a white, yellow, rose gold, or platinum band.

etsy moissanite ring

Round Moissanite Ring 

Etsy • $349+

Striking out searching for perfect vintage diamond rings, Etsy offers an alternative with this affordable vintage-looking handmade Moissanite ring. With a round center cut and dainty pear-shaped accent stones make this dainty ring unique and beautiful.

oval cut-etsy moissanite engagement ring

Oval Cut Moissanite Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $99.56+

You can’t beat the price or the look of this 3 stone oval-cut Moissanite engagement ring. It also comes with its own velvet ring box.

cushion cut-etsy moissanite ring

Cushion Cut Moissanite Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $359+

This Cushion cut ring sparkles beautifully with accent stones that wrap almost all the way around the band. Your band can be made from 9k, 14k, 18k gold or platinum.

emerald cut-etsy moissanite engagement ring

Emerald Cut Moissanite Engagement Ring

Etsy • $176.33+

An Emerald cut ring always makes a statement, and this one especially because not only does it shine, it also costs about a tenth of the price of regular diamonds.  You can get the band in sterling silver, yellow, white, or rose gold.

Etsy Gold Rings

Trends come and go. We all know this. For a while, a yellow gold band ring was the standard, but for whatever reason, yellow gold took a backseat to platinum.  Thank goodness the yellow gold band didn’t completely disappear because the rings below are absolutely gorgeous.

pear cut-etsy gold rings

Pear Cut Moissanite Ring 

Etsy • $2049+

If you’ve been searching for Etsy art deco engagement rings, then look no further than Szeki Studio. This pear-cut, teardrop moissanite ring will make anyone say yes atop this yellow gold band.

oval cut-etsy gold rings

Yellow Gold Vermeil Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $75

This CZ yellow gold ring can also be made with a moissanite gemstone.  Whatever stone you choose, you will be happy with this sterling silver band heavy plated with yellow gold that is guaranteed not to rust or turn your finger green.

classic cut-engagement rings etsy

Classic Round Cut Solitaire Ring 

Etsy • $198

We love the classic look of this six-prong solitaire setting. The band is made of solid 10k yellow or white gold and is allergy-free and tarnish-resistant.

Marquise cut-etsy diamond rings

Marquise Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $893.62+

There is something so unique about a Marquise cut ring. The contrast of the moissanite against the yellow gold makes for a striking engagement ring.

solid gold-etsy gold rings

Solid Gold Moissanite Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $82+

This ring 1.0 ct art deco engagement ring features a moissanite stone with a solid gold band. This ring also has sustainable features like recyclable metals.

Etsy Rose Gold Ring

Rose gold became popular in the 1920s but had a resurgence of sorts around 2015  when we started hearing the term “Millennial Pink.”  Rose gold showed up on our Apple iPhones, on the catwalk, and even on wedding cakes! We love a good nod to pink, and after the 2023 Blockbuster Barbie, shades of pink are obviously here to stay.  So check out some of our favorite Etsy rose gold rings.

infinity-etsy rose gold ring

Rose Gold Infinity Moissanite Wedding Ring 

Etsy • $532+

The rose gold looks amazing and is heavily featured in this setting with an infinity twist band. If you’re also looking for an Etsy ring set, this seller also offers several wedding bands that would work well.

oval moissanite-etsy rose gold ring

Halo Rose Gold Cluster Ring 

Etsy • $536.53+

This Halo cut rose gold cluster ring and matching wedding band in rose gold will knock anyone’s socks off. Made with a center stone of Moissanite, you can also choose diamond side stones on the band or around the center stone.

engagement-etsy rose gold ring

Pearl Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $480

Pearls and rose gold are a winning combination much like you and your future spouse. We love this dainty rose gold pearl engagement ring with real diamonds.

solitare-etsy rose gold ring

Round Solitaire Rose Gold Ring 

Etsy • $93

This 2.25 ct diamond simulant is made in Poland and features the same sparkle and shine as a natural diamond. The rose gold band peaks out around the gemstones on the band for a lovely look.

vermil-etsy rose gold ring

Rose Gold Vermeil Ring 

Etsy • $78.48

This pink Morganite art deco ring looks flawless with a rose gold band. If you are looking for lookalike vintage rings, Etsy has you covered, and with a great price.

Etsy Black Diamond Ring

If you or your partner want something completely unique consider looking for black diamond engagement rings on Etsy. Black diamonds are diamonds with black coloring, which are usually from some minerals like graphite that make them black.  If you don’t want to pay for the actual black diamond, Onyx is a great alternative. Here are some beautiful Etsy black diamond rings.

black diamond engagement rings etsy

Black Onyx Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $115+

This ring will turn heads. With a 4ct Emerald cut Onyx stone with Moissanite clusters flanking each side, you’ll have a one-of-a-kind ring.

black diamond engagement rings etsy

Black Onyx Solitaire Ring 

Etsy • $153.57+

This art-deco style ring features a center Onyx stone in a halo setting with onyx stones surrounding the outside. It can be set in a yellow, white, or rose gold setting.

5 stone black-engagement rings etsy

Five Stone Black Spinel Ring 

Etsy • $146+

This pear-cut black Onyx ring gives huge vintage art deco vibes. The five stones consist of a center Onyx gemstone with black spinel accent stones and a unique twig leaf design on the band.

quartz-black diamond engagement rings etsy

Rutilated Quartz Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $548.51+

If you haven’t considered rutilated quartz for your engagement ring, then this is your sign.  This beautiful ring is made to order and can come in different metal bands.

Etsy Vintage Engagement Rings

If you weren’t bequeathed an antique or vintage ring from a relative, never fret. You can still have vintage rings, Etsy is the best marketplace for vintage and antique jewelry. It’s the beauty of scouring the best estate sales from all over the world in one place. Check out some of our favorite Etsy antique rings below.

etsy antique rings

Vintage Diamond Engagement Ring

Etsy • $400

This 1980s cathedral setting 10k yellow gold .6 ct diamond ring is what retro dreams are made of.  It’s affordable and unique.

etsy vintage rings

Green Sapphire Diamond Cluster Ring  

Etsy • $2,890+

This Montana Sapphire pear ring with diamond clusters is a rare find. You and your ring will stand out on your big day.

etsy vintage engagement rings

Oval Moissanite Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $550+

This vintage ring is from the 1990s or later and features an oval moissanite center stone with natural diamond side stones to accent. The band is available in white, yellow, or rose gold.

gemstone engagement rings etsy

Vintage Aquamarine Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $1,430.79+

This ring from Sunday Island Jewelry “evokes the elegance of medieval ladies who lived in mesmerizing castles.” The center stone is a beautiful clear blue aquamarine any bride will love to wear.

vintage-gemstone engagement rings etsy

Vintage & Antique 1930s Art Deco 

Etsy • $3,000

This Etsy antique engagement ring is from the 1930s. The European-cut diamond is framed by four corner prongs. The band features a unique chain link design accented with delicately studded single-cut diamonds.

Non-Diamond Engagement Rings on Etsy

Some of the best Etsy engagement ring shops feature rings without diamonds. The best part of rocking a non-diamond engagement ring is that you can get more bang for your buck when it comes to the weight of the gemstone, and you will definitely be going against the status quo showcasing your own unique personality.  Here are some of our favorites below.

non diamond engagement rings etsy

Marquise Amethyst Engagement Ring  

Etsy • $1,550+

This ring from Jewelry by Garo features a handmade Marquise cut 1.38 ct Amethyst ring surrounded by 12 natural white diamonds. The best of both worlds in our opinion.

etsy unique engagement rings

Blue Sapphire Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $2,915

We are in love with this blue Sapphire kite engagement ring from Hiddenspace Shop. The unique curve cut of the band is stunning and won’t be found anywhere else.

sapphire-non diamond engagement rings etsy

Olive Green Sapphire Ring 

Etsy • $3,750

This ring from Eidel Precious features a beautiful, clean, and sparkling 2 ct. green sapphire, set in a 14k rose gold diamond setting.  You’ll look and feel like an angel with this halo setting.

three stone-non diamond engagement rings etsy

Marquise Diamond Three-Stone Ring 

Etsy • $1,045

Looking for unique gemstone engagement rings? Etsy has you covered. Case in point: this non-traditional diamond and tanzanite ring.

peacock sapphire-non diamond engagement rings etsy

Peacock Sapphire Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $494+

This oval-cut blue-green Sapphire is surrounded by a cluster of moissanite and set in rose gold.  You can choose from natural diamonds and other metals as well.

non diamond engagement rings etsy

Cluster Garnet Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $172+

This ring checks all the boxes. Looking for unique gemstones? This offers lab lab-created garnet. Cz diamonds and natural moss agate. Want different shapes? Then you’ll find it with hexagonal and marquise cuts in this ring.

Handmade Unique Engagement Rings

Finally, if you can’t find what you are looking for, then consider a custom ring that is handmade with care. Etsy is your source for all things handmade and unique, so when it comes to looking for those characteristics in your engagement ring, you won’t be disappointed.  Here is just a snapshot of some of the beautiful custom rings available.

natural opal-handmade unique engagement rings

Natural Opal Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $146.63+

This stunning oval Opal Engagement Ring is a great choice for couples looking for a unique and ethereal piece of jewelry. This handmade ring features a beautiful natural opal stone, expertly cut and polished to showcase its stunning play of colors.

etsy art deco engagement rings

Silver Branch & Dainty Rose Quartz Ring 

Etsy • $125

If you’re looking for men’s engagement rings, Etsy offers plenty of options. This ring mixes elements of masculine and feminine.

hexagon-vintage diamond rings etsy

Hexagon Cut Moissanite Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $536+

This looks like it is straight out of the 1920s. The hexagon Bezel set is so beautiful and one-of-a-kind it will take your breath away.

handmade unique engagement rings

Oval Blue Topaz Woodland Engagement Ring 

Etsy • $138+

The band gives a woodland vibe, and the oval blue Topaz gemstone is straight out of a fairytale. You’ll feel like a princess in this ring.

multi stone-handmade unique engagement rings

White Topaz Multi-Stone Unique Ring 

Etsy • $64.99

This white Topaz natural Peridot ring is made to order. We love an Emerald cut, but especially when it’s set unusually like this one.

Does Etsy sell real gold?

Yes, Etsy does. However, it’s important to look for the right words and keywords when doing your search. Solid gold is often a good search term, but look at the listing for phrases like gold-plated.  Also, the pricing will indicate if you are looking at real gold or gold-plated listings and always read the reviews.

Is Etsy jewelry real?

As always, do your research. By that, we mean that you should read all the details about the product, including the fine print of the metals. If you have any lingering questions after reviewing the product description, always ask the seller!

Are Etsy engagement rings legit?

Buying online is a great way to purchase your or your fiance’s engagement ring because you will be able to find unique designs that may not be available in traditional jewelry stores.  Etsy provides a great blog when it comes to shopping for rings online that you can read here. One of their tips that we would also echo is to shop from star sellers on their site!

Why are Etsy rings so cheap?

Sellers on Etsy can offer you a great price because they don’t have to worry about covering the overhead costs when it comes to marketing or production costs.  They can cut out the corporate fees and offer you a better price, and you are supporting small business owners. It’s a win-win.

What Etsy engagement ring style would you choose for your big day?

Join us in our community to talk about the best Etsy engagement rings!


Emily Perry is a freelance blogger, content manager, designer, and virtual assistant. Although her own wedding was over 10 years she loves talking about all things wedding especially when it comes to saving money and DIY!